ARTICLE VIDEO

PR

Making Music With AI: Soundraw, Splash Pro, CassetteAI and Soundful Compared

Gear & SoftwarePublished 2024.02.29Updated 2026.07.17
Read article ↓

This practical comparison explores ways music producers can use generative AI in their workflow. We test Soundraw, Splash Pro, CassetteAI and Soundful, comparing their sound, features and subscription costs, including stems, MIDI export, vocal generation and editing tools. This is a historical comparison originally published in February 2024: the prices, plans, offers and capabilities described reflect that test, rather than a current service or pricing guide.

How can music producers use AI services?

AI Music

We have been covering AI services more frequently in our content.
So far, we have introduced tools for virtual instruments, effects, mastering and other tasks.

This time, we turn to services that generate the music itself: generative music AI. That is the focus of this comparison.
We chose tools that seemed particularly compatible with DAW production and use and compare four AI services while creating an original background-music track. This gives us a practical way to evaluate them.
We will explore each service's strengths and how it can contribute to music production.

Video: Making Music With Generative AI

Sponsor: Introducing Soundraw

This project was made possible by Soundraw, the generative music AI service, which sponsored the original comparison.
The original February 2024 promotion advertised the checkout coupon code SLEEPFREAKS for 50% off. That is the offer recorded in the original article, not a confirmation that it remains available.
Check the service's current terms before purchasing.

What is a generative music AI service?

Music generation

A generative music AI service uses AI to create audio recordings of music automatically. That is the basic idea.
It can generate melodies, chord progressions and rhythm patterns across many genres.

One service attracting attention at the time of this comparison was suno.ai. It was another example of this approach.
It could generate complete vocal tracks and lyrics, but the options available to producers for working with the results were relatively limited in the version tested.

For that reason, we selected the services in this comparison with features useful for further music production as our main criterion.

The AI services in this comparison

We compare the following four generative music AI services.
The table records the standard monthly-plan prices shown in the original February 2024 comparison, not current prices.

Service CassetteAI Splash Pro Soundraw Soundful
Monthly price in the original comparison US$3.99 US$49 US$16.99 US$10
Maximum generated duration in the test 300 seconds 420 seconds 300 seconds Not selectable
BPM/key control Not available Preset selection Available Available
Stem download Available Available Higher plan required (US$35.99 at the time) Available
  • Beyond sound quality, these services differed in maximum duration, key and BPM control, and other features.
  • At the time of the test, Soundraw's batch export required a higher-tier Artist plan.

Hearing each service's generated music

First, let's generate some music and listen to each service's output.
We requested a relaxed track suitable for background music, at around 90 BPM.

CassetteAI example

We liked the atmosphere, although the output had some unstable textures and nuances characteristic of the AI-generated examples in this test.

Splash Pro example

The track had a clear sense of development, but we found the audio somewhat rough.

Soundraw example

The track arrangement felt economical and purposeful. Although the detail was relatively simple, the sound was clear.

Soundful example

The arrangement felt full, and the sound was among the clearer examples in the comparison.

These observations mainly concern the character of the generated sound. In this test, we felt Soundraw and Soundful were already usable for practical production. Those were the reviewer's impressions of these examples.

Listening to Suno.ai as well

For comparison, let's also hear a service that generates an entire song: Suno.ai. Here is its output.

Because this example includes vocals, it is less suitable as instrumental background music or as a backing for your own vocal. Still, we were impressed by its clear musical structure and development.
We felt the clarity of the audio still had room to improve in this example.

Distinctive features of each service

Next, we will look at features and options that can be useful for producing music beyond the initial generation.

CassetteAI: stem and MIDI export

Despite its low price in the original comparison, CassetteAI offered several ways to work with individual parts.

You could preview each instrument type separately and check what a stem contained before exporting. That was useful when you wanted to use only a particular part.

At export, you could download separate stems for the tracks.
However, some stems contained traces of other parts. If you needed cleaner separation, further adjustment could be necessary.

A MIDI-export option was also available.
It converted the performance of each part into MIDI data that could be imported into a DAW.
We felt that the MIDI accuracy needed improvement, however, and manual editing was necessary.

You could also upload a reference track to guide generation more specifically.
The reference was limited to 60 seconds, and the generated result often did not resemble it particularly closely.
We liked the idea, but felt it still had substantial room to develop.

Our honest impression was that CassetteAI offered many features at a low price, but fell short of some other services in practical usability during this test.

Splash Pro: generating lyrics and vocals

Splash Pro did not provide detailed controls over the generated music, but it supported lyric, vocal and rap generation.

Although lyric generation was limited to English in the tested version, choosing different singer voices for vocals or rap was interesting. It could also help generate ideas for vocal melodies.
Stems, including the vocals, could be downloaded. We found it useful when seeking an a cappella vocal with chosen lyrics.

Another distinctive feature generated animated lyric videos from the music.
Its original price was comparatively high, but it offered an unusual combination of features.

Soundraw: flexible arrangements and clear sound

Its range of editing options after generation was a major strength and fitted well with a DAW workflow.

You could adjust the intensity and fills of individual tracks.
Although it was an AI-generation tool, it addressed specific production needs. For demo work, it was useful to arrange the song directly in the browser.

Instrument let you choose sounds used in the track, making the service useful for both quick demos and generating musical ideas.

In the original comparison, stem download was available only with the higher-tier Artist Pro plan, listed at US$35.99 per month.

To download all stems directly, you needed to upgrade to that plan.
However, the Creator plan also allowed individual parts to be downloaded through a more manual process in the workflow tested.

In the editor, mute the unwanted tracks so that only the part you want to download remains audible, then download that version.
Varying the intensity and fills lets you create samples with more possibilities than a single fixed audio loop.

Soundraw offered features such as sound selection and a variety of pattern variations.
Those options made it a useful service for producers in this comparison.

Soundful: downloading individual tracks

You could specify the generated music by selecting a mood, genre and subgenre.

Paid packs created in collaboration with particular artists also offered a way to generate music in a preferred style.

Export options were another strength.
Alongside downloading the individual tracks in a song, MIDI-file export was supported in the workflow described in the original comparison.

Producers could edit the parts in detail in their own DAW and incorporate them into a track.
That made it a promising option for users seeking generated audio material.


What did you think of the comparison?

We hope it gives you a sense of how quickly generative music AI was developing, and the possibilities we saw in it.
This field can change in months or even weeks, so it is worth continuing to follow its development.

At the time of this test, we particularly hoped for improvements in these areas:

  • The emphasis was largely on electronic genres.
  • There was limited control over specific compositional details such as chord progressions and melodies.

Even so, we found substantial value for brainstorming, gathering source material and studying song structure.

For example, AI could generate part of a track or provide inspiration for a song's development.
Combining those strengths with an existing music-production workflow seemed to us the most effective approach at the time.

Try exploring a service that interests you and consider how its output could fit into your own production process.
Thank you for reading to the end.

Sponsor: Introducing Soundraw

This project was made possible by Soundraw, the generative music AI service, which sponsored the original comparison.
The original February 2024 promotion advertised the checkout coupon code SLEEPFREAKS for 50% off. This records the original offer; its current availability has not been verified.
Check the service's current terms before purchasing.

Frequently asked questions

Q1. Which generative music AI service stood out for DAW production?

In the original test, Soundraw and Soundful offered a good balance of sound quality and practical usability. Soundraw provided extensive editing, while Soundful produced full arrangements. The best fit depends on the task; these are historical test impressions.

Q2. Can AI-generated music be edited in a DAW?

The services tested offered stem or MIDI export options, depending on the product and plan. CassetteAI also exported MIDI for DAW import, although its results sometimes required manual correction.

Q3. Which service in this test offered vocal tracks?

Splash Pro supported English lyric generation, vocals and rap in different singer voices, with stems that included the vocals. This describes the version tested in February 2024.

Q4. Which service was least expensive in the original comparison?

CassetteAI had the lowest listed monthly price, US$3.99. It offered stem and MIDI export, although we felt its sound consistency and accuracy needed improvement compared with the more expensive options tested.

Q5. Which services worked well for background music?

We found Soundraw and Soundful well suited to that task in this comparison. Soundraw in particular offered BPM and key control, flexible arrangements and extensive editing features.